For decades, BMI has been the default measure for assessing health risks linked to weight. But while it’s easy to calculate, BMI has serious flaws—it can’t distinguish between fat and muscle, and it ignores fat distribution. Enter the Body Roundness Index (BRI), a newer metric that might finally offer a more precise look at obesity-related health risks.
What’s Wrong with BMI?

BMI’s simplicity is also its downfall. It classifies bodybuilders as obese, treats all fat as equal, and offers no insights into where fat is located—especially the high-risk abdominal fat linked to diseases like diabetes and heart disease. Dr. Manfred Müller, a nutrition expert, says BMI was “always a very crude measure” for identifying health risks.
BRI: A Better Way?
BRI, developed in 2013, uses waist circumference and height to capture body “roundness” rather than just weight. Unlike BMI, it zooms in on abdominal fat, which is a major factor in heart disease, diabetes, and metabolic disorders. Recent studies back BRI’s potential. A 2023 study in JAMA Network Open found that both very high and very low BRI scores correlated with higher mortality risk. Another study linked a rising BRI with increased cardiovascular risk, signaling it might be a more accurate predictor of long-term health.
BMI’s “Healthy Obese” Paradox
BMI often mislabels people. Some with a BMI over 30 don’t suffer from high blood pressure, diabetes, or high cholesterol. Müller suggests that BMI’s imprecision is partly to blame for this “healthy obese” category. BRI, with its focus on waist measurements, could help doctors identify these at-risk patients earlier and more accurately.
Can BRI Replace BMI?
Despite its promise, replacing BMI with BRI won’t be easy. BMI is deeply embedded in healthcare guidelines, growth charts, and even medication dosages. Changing the system would require extensive validation of BRI across diverse age, gender, and ethnic groups.
Plus, as Dr. Diana Thomas, a BRI co-creator, points out, indices like BMI and BRI are more useful for general assessments than scientific research. To dig deeper into obesity’s health effects, researchers need high-precision tools like DEXA or MRI scans.
The Future of Weight Assessment
BRI could reshape how we assess health risks in clinical settings, offering a sharper focus on visceral fat and related diseases. However, for now, it may be best as a supplement to BMI rather than a replacement. If you’re a doctor—or a patient—seeking a clearer picture of obesity’s health impacts, BRI might just be a step in the right direction.
In my weight loss clinic I am already using the waist:height ratio for patients that display visible belly fat but who may have a low BMI. I believe that this gives a better picture of their cardiovascular health risk.


